Tamil Nadu vs governor: ‘SC verdict may create imbalance in federal structure’ | India News

Article arrow_drop_down

[ad_1]

Tamil Nadu vs governor: 'SC verdict may create imbalance in federal structure'

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court‘s recent decision to clear 10 bills passed by Tamil Nadu assembly without the assent of state governor RN Ravi and the top court’s move to fix timelines for all governors and President to act on bills passed by the states has been hailed as “historic” and “a victory for federalism” by several opposition parties amid reports that the Centre may file a review petition against the verdict.
The SC bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and R Mahadevan, without mincing words, said “where the governor reserves a bill for the consideration of the President and the President in turn withholds assent thereto then, it shall be open to the state government to assail such an action before this court”.
Observing that a governor is required to abide by the aid and advice tendered by the council of ministers, the top court said it is not open for a governor to reserve a bill for the consideration of the President once it is presented to him in the second round, after having been returned to the House previously.
Further, what makes the verdict more significant is the court’s invocation of its extraordinary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution. This provision allows the Supreme Court to deliver “complete justice” in cases where no direct legal remedy may exist. And in this case, justice came in the form of a stern reminder: governors are not above the Constitution, and their role is not to act as gatekeepers for political interests.
The apex court also provided a resort to the state government and said that if a governor reserves a bill for the President’s consideration and the President subsequently withholds assent, the state government has the right to challenge that decision before the Supreme Court.
While the verdict has been welcomed by chief ministers of non-BJP ruled states, senior SC advocate Vivek Narayan Sharma argues that it might create “an imbalance in the federal structure if not tempered with constitutional discipline.”
Speaking to TOI, he said, “The political turf war between states and governors, especially in opposition ruled territories, will persist. What has changed is the axis of power: the upper hand now tilts towards the States. While this strengthens state legislative autonomy, it may also create an imbalance in the federal structure if not tempered with constitutional discipline,” when asked if the verdict would affect future tussles between governors and chief ministers of non-BJP ruled states.

Different-engine government vs double-engine government

The SC judgment comes as the Centre and several state governments, especially the ones not rightly aligned, have engaged in a power tussle over getting the bills cleared.
The opposition has accused the BJP-led central government of using governors in non-BJP ruled states as a weapon to create friction with the governments – be it in Kerala, West Bengal, Karnataka, Punjab or Tamil Nadu by delaying the passage of bills.
Tamil Nadu CM MK Stalin had remarked that the Centre was running a “parallel government” through governors adding that it was not “just against federal principles but also against the Indian Constitution. India is now witnessing cheap politics by governors, who are unfit to hold such high posts.”
Last year, the top court had taken note of West Bengal and Kerala governments, both embroiled in prolonged standoffs with their respective governors over delayed assent to bills.
Kerala, led by the CPM’s Left Democratic Front, approached the court in March, arguing that its governor had wrongly referred seven bills—unrelated to Centre-state matters—to the President, leaving them pending for up to two years. The state claimed this move undermined the legislature’s authority.
Similarly, West Bengal, governed by the Trinamool Congress, alleged that its governor withheld assent on eight bills and hurriedly referred some to the President once the court hearing loomed.
In Punjab’s case, the SC had strongly cautioned then-governor Banwarilal Purohit, warning, “you are playing with fire.” The court voiced serious concern over the legislative deadlock in the state and took a tough stance on the governor’s failure to grant assent to bills passed by the state assembly.

A two-way battle?

And while the opposition ruled states are celebrating this verdict, there are instances when they have also opposed implementing Central legislations. Recently, Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee and Tamil Nadu CM MK Stalin denied to implement centrally-approved Waqf Act, Kerala government opposed the Citizenship Amendment Act, and Punjab government passed resolution against the now-repealed farm laws. Clearly, it is a tug of war, with both the Centre and the State calling their shots wherever they can. However, the Centre, with governors under their control, perhaps has more weapons in its armor.
Also, the state governments don’t have the privilege to sit over bills as the governors do. Hence, the SC noted in the recent verdict that the governor must be the “harbinger of consensus and resolution, lubricating the functioning of the State machinery by his sagacity, wisdom and not run it into a standstill. He must be the catalyst and not an inhibitor. All his actions must be impelled keeping in mind the dignity of the high constitutional office that he occupies”.
The verdict under question, however, “shifts the constitutional balance in favour of the states,” Sharma said.
“This judgment undoubtedly shifts the constitutional balance in favour of the States. It diminishes the discretionary space traditionally accorded to governors—even in cases where the Constitution explicitly provides for it. While sometimes states may be right, and at other times the governor may be, “rightness” must always be judged through the lens of the Constitution—not individual ideologies or political agendas,” he said when asked if the verdict would impact future tussles between the Centre and the states.
However, Parliament has the power to pass legislations to overturn SC judgements. Talking about such a possibility, Sharma said, “There is strong likelihood that the judgment would be reconsidered by a constitution bench of the Supreme Court and the directions and mandate of this judgment would be stayed till the decision by a larger bench. However, if for any reason, the above doesn’t happen, then the government should consider to amend the law to remove anomalies this judgment would bring in the executive and parliament domain.”



[ad_2]

Source link

About the author

Kamal Haasan in Thug Life styled by Amritha Ram
trending_flat
Designing Thug Life: Amritha Ram on Styling Kamal Haasan

Costume design in Indian cinema often dances between fantasy and realism. But in Thug Life, Amritha Ram collaborates with cinematic icons Kamal Haasan and Mani Ratnam to craft a fashion-forward yet character-driven wardrobe that breaks norms. In an exclusive with ETimes, Amritha reveals how meticulous planning, storytelling, and visual language drove her designs. Tip 1: Collaboration Is the Key to Vision When asked what excited her most about working on Thug Life, Amritha simply said, “Two names: Kamal Haasan and Mani Ratnam.” The sheer reputation of these legends shaped her approach. Mani Ratnam was clear about the film’s visual tone—stripping away Bollywood glamor for something minimalistic yet powerful. “Mani sir guided me all the way. He knew exactly what he wanted,” she shared. Working with Kamal, who understands fabric, dyeing, and even costume history, was a learning curve. His feedback […]

trending_flat
If It Happened There: Donald Trump sends central troops to quell protests in opposition-ruled California | World News

[ad_1] Protesters confront police on the 101 Freeway near the Metropolitan Detention Center of downtown Los Angeles, Sunday, June 8, 2025, following last night's immigration raid protest. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong) Note: The following piece is inspired by Joshua Keating’s If It Happened There which uses tropes and tones normally used by American media to describe events in other countries. The facts presented deal with as much exactitude and accuracy as an American media outlets’ reporting about a foreign country.Los Angeles, Mexican for the city of angels, is home to Hollywood – America’s answer to Bollywood – and a city where starstruck aspirants come with the dream of being immortalised on the silver screen. Yet, the city, which falls under America-administered California, an opposition state which overwhelmingly voted for Mr Donald Trump’s rival from the Democratic Party, Ms Kamala Harris, […]

trending_flat
Apple prepares for new ‘Games’ app as domain goes live ahead of WWDC 2025 keynote

[ad_1] Apple is expected to launch iOS 19 (or rumoured iOS 26) and one of new features that is reported to come is a new Apple Games app. Apple appears to be laying the groundwork for this new application, which is said to curate games from the App Store and Apple Arcade, as a domain purportedly leading to the platform has gone live.As per a report by 9to5mac, the company's new games.apple.com domain has just gone live. However, it is currently displaying a blank page, signaling imminent content.This shift from a "Safari Can’t Find The Server" error message to a blank white page strongly suggests Apple is preparing to push content to the URL very soon, potentially coinciding with the conclusion of the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) keynote.What Apple’s new Games app is all aboutWhile the exact function of the […]

trending_flat
MS Dhoni inducted into ICC Hall of Fame | Cricket News

[ad_1] MS Dhoni, former India cricket captain, has been inducted into the ICC Cricket Hall of Fame, recognizing his extraordinary career spanning 16 years with 17,266 international runs, 829 dismissals and 538 matches across formats for India. The wicketkeeper-batsman revolutionized the sport through his unique playing style, tactical leadership and achievements including winning all three ICC men's white-ball titles as captain. "It is an honour to be named in the ICC Hall of Fame, which recognises the contributions of cricketers across generations and from all over the world. To have your name remembered alongside such all-time greats is a wonderful feeling. It is something that I will cherish forever," Dhoni said about his induction. Dhoni's journey began in 2004 when he made his ODI debut. Though he was dismissed for a duck in his first match, he soon announced his […]

trending_flat
160-million-year-old blue-stain fungi in China found to be harmful to trees |

[ad_1] In a groundbreaking discovery, researchers have uncovered 160-million-year-old blue-stain fungi fossils from the Jurassic Tiaojishan Formation in China. The new findings offer fresh insights into the ecological relationships between blue-stain fungi, plants, and insects during the Jurassic period. These fungi are generally nonfatal to their hosts but often accelerate tree mortality when associated with wood-boring insects.According to ScienceDaily, a Chinese team of scientists highlights the discovery of well-preserved blue-stain fungal hyphae within Jurassic fossil wood from northeastern China, pushing back the earliest known fossil record of this fungal group by approximately 80 million years.Know about the blue-stain fungi, deadly to treesBlue-stain fungi are known for their ability to colonize wood, particularly in conifer trees, causing characteristic discoloration in the sapwood. While these fungi do not decompose wood, they often cause considerable damage when associated with wood-boring insects. Their role […]

trending_flat
America burning: LA reels under anti-immigration protests for third straight day despite Trump’s National Guard order

[ad_1] Multiple Waymo taxis burn near the Metropolitan Detention Center of downtown Los Angeles, following last night's immigration raid protest. (Video credit: X) For the third night in a row, downtown Los Angeles became the epicentre of chaos and confrontation as protests against US President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown boiled over into violence, with police deploying tear gas, rubber bullets, and flashbangs to subdue demonstrators. Protesters set self-driving cars ablaze, blocked the 101 freeway, and clashed with law enforcement late into Sunday night, leaving parts of the city scorched and on edge.The flashpoint came after Trump took the extraordinary step of deploying the National Guard to California without the consent of the state's governor, an act not seen in decades. More than 300 troops arrived over the weekend, with 2,000 authorised and 500 US Marines on standby.Meanwhile, California governor Gavin […]

Related

Kamal Haasan in Thug Life styled by Amritha Ram
trending_flat
Designing Thug Life: Amritha Ram on Styling Kamal Haasan

Costume design in Indian cinema often dances between fantasy and realism. But in Thug Life, Amritha Ram collaborates with cinematic icons Kamal Haasan and Mani Ratnam to craft a fashion-forward yet character-driven wardrobe that breaks norms. In an exclusive with ETimes, Amritha reveals how meticulous planning, storytelling, and visual language drove her designs. Tip 1: Collaboration Is the Key to Vision When asked what excited her most about working on Thug Life, Amritha simply said, “Two names: Kamal Haasan and Mani Ratnam.” The sheer reputation of these legends shaped her approach. Mani Ratnam was clear about the film’s visual tone—stripping away Bollywood glamor for something minimalistic yet powerful. “Mani sir guided me all the way. He knew exactly what he wanted,” she shared. Working with Kamal, who understands fabric, dyeing, and even costume history, was a learning curve. His feedback […]

trending_flat
If It Happened There: Donald Trump sends central troops to quell protests in opposition-ruled California | World News

[ad_1] Protesters confront police on the 101 Freeway near the Metropolitan Detention Center of downtown Los Angeles, Sunday, June 8, 2025, following last night's immigration raid protest. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong) Note: The following piece is inspired by Joshua Keating’s If It Happened There which uses tropes and tones normally used by American media to describe events in other countries. The facts presented deal with as much exactitude and accuracy as an American media outlets’ reporting about a foreign country.Los Angeles, Mexican for the city of angels, is home to Hollywood – America’s answer to Bollywood – and a city where starstruck aspirants come with the dream of being immortalised on the silver screen. Yet, the city, which falls under America-administered California, an opposition state which overwhelmingly voted for Mr Donald Trump’s rival from the Democratic Party, Ms Kamala Harris, […]

trending_flat
Apple prepares for new ‘Games’ app as domain goes live ahead of WWDC 2025 keynote

[ad_1] Apple is expected to launch iOS 19 (or rumoured iOS 26) and one of new features that is reported to come is a new Apple Games app. Apple appears to be laying the groundwork for this new application, which is said to curate games from the App Store and Apple Arcade, as a domain purportedly leading to the platform has gone live.As per a report by 9to5mac, the company's new games.apple.com domain has just gone live. However, it is currently displaying a blank page, signaling imminent content.This shift from a "Safari Can’t Find The Server" error message to a blank white page strongly suggests Apple is preparing to push content to the URL very soon, potentially coinciding with the conclusion of the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) keynote.What Apple’s new Games app is all aboutWhile the exact function of the […]

trending_flat
MS Dhoni inducted into ICC Hall of Fame | Cricket News

[ad_1] MS Dhoni, former India cricket captain, has been inducted into the ICC Cricket Hall of Fame, recognizing his extraordinary career spanning 16 years with 17,266 international runs, 829 dismissals and 538 matches across formats for India. The wicketkeeper-batsman revolutionized the sport through his unique playing style, tactical leadership and achievements including winning all three ICC men's white-ball titles as captain. "It is an honour to be named in the ICC Hall of Fame, which recognises the contributions of cricketers across generations and from all over the world. To have your name remembered alongside such all-time greats is a wonderful feeling. It is something that I will cherish forever," Dhoni said about his induction. Dhoni's journey began in 2004 when he made his ODI debut. Though he was dismissed for a duck in his first match, he soon announced his […]

trending_flat
160-million-year-old blue-stain fungi in China found to be harmful to trees |

[ad_1] In a groundbreaking discovery, researchers have uncovered 160-million-year-old blue-stain fungi fossils from the Jurassic Tiaojishan Formation in China. The new findings offer fresh insights into the ecological relationships between blue-stain fungi, plants, and insects during the Jurassic period. These fungi are generally nonfatal to their hosts but often accelerate tree mortality when associated with wood-boring insects.According to ScienceDaily, a Chinese team of scientists highlights the discovery of well-preserved blue-stain fungal hyphae within Jurassic fossil wood from northeastern China, pushing back the earliest known fossil record of this fungal group by approximately 80 million years.Know about the blue-stain fungi, deadly to treesBlue-stain fungi are known for their ability to colonize wood, particularly in conifer trees, causing characteristic discoloration in the sapwood. While these fungi do not decompose wood, they often cause considerable damage when associated with wood-boring insects. Their role […]

trending_flat
America burning: LA reels under anti-immigration protests for third straight day despite Trump’s National Guard order

[ad_1] Multiple Waymo taxis burn near the Metropolitan Detention Center of downtown Los Angeles, following last night's immigration raid protest. (Video credit: X) For the third night in a row, downtown Los Angeles became the epicentre of chaos and confrontation as protests against US President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown boiled over into violence, with police deploying tear gas, rubber bullets, and flashbangs to subdue demonstrators. Protesters set self-driving cars ablaze, blocked the 101 freeway, and clashed with law enforcement late into Sunday night, leaving parts of the city scorched and on edge.The flashpoint came after Trump took the extraordinary step of deploying the National Guard to California without the consent of the state's governor, an act not seen in decades. More than 300 troops arrived over the weekend, with 2,000 authorised and 500 US Marines on standby.Meanwhile, California governor Gavin […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

“At PostyHive, we empower creators and thinkers to Explore, Share, and Connect, building a community where diverse ideas and passions thrive. Join us on this journey of discovery!”

About PostyHive

#PostyHive is a dynamic online community where individuals can explore, share, and connect over diverse topics, from technology and lifestyle to entertainment and wellness. Join us on this journey to inspire and engage with a wealth of knowledge and experiences!

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation